A strategy is your theory on how to win in business, and a plan is the list of what gets done this year, by when, to act on that theory. EOS keeps the two apart too, putting its Marketing Strategy on the Vision page of the V/TO and its 1-Year Plan and quarterly Rocks on the Traction page, and mixing them up can cost real money: in the example below, the same $50 of ad spend either earns $94 or loses $14 per customer, depending on whether the theory behind the plan holds.
A plan can be carried out perfectly and still lose money. That happens when nobody checks the theory underneath it.
What Is a Strategy?
A strategy is a theory on how to win in business: where you choose to compete, and why customers will pick you there. It's one of my 7 Ps, the framework I use to run a company, where I call it Position. It sits between Purpose and Product. Your purpose informs your strategy, and your strategy informs what you sell.
The word that matters is theory. A theory can be wrong, so it has to be tested, and it changes when the evidence says it should. Strategy is fluid and changeable. It is not a plan.
What Is a Plan?
A plan is a list of things to do, with owners, dates, and numbers attached. It answers what, who, and by when. Unlike a theory, a plan doesn't need to be argued about every month. It needs to be done.
Where Does EOS Put Strategy and Plan?
EOS, the Entrepreneurial Operating System, uses a two-page tool called the V/TO, the Vision/Traction Organizer. Its own guide to the V/TO lists five sections on the Vision page: Core Values, Core Focus, 10-Year Target, Marketing Strategy, and 3-Year Picture. The Traction page has three: the 1-Year Plan, Rocks, and the Issues List.
On the strategy side, EOS calls its Marketing Strategy "the four-part framework that defines how a company goes to market." The four parts are a target market, three uniques, a proven process, and a guarantee.
On the plan side, EOS says the 1-Year Plan "translates your 3-Year Picture™ into this year’s specific goals." It holds a revenue target, a profit target, a few measurables, and "three to seven goals the company must accomplish this year." Rocks are three to seven priorities for the next 90 days, set against the 1-Year Plan.
Credit where it's due. EOS gives strategy more structure than I do. Four named parts are easier to fill in on a Tuesday afternoon than "write your theory on how to win," and the 1-Year Plan is a clean, usable plan format. The 7 Ps don't have a planning template by name.
Should Your Strategy Change More Often Than EOS Suggests?
The difference I care about is how tightly each one holds strategy. EOS's Marketing Strategy page says "A good Marketing Strategy is stable. Refine over time; do not reinvent every year." I'd hold it more loosely than that. In the 7 Ps, the thing that never changes is Purpose. Strategy is a theory, and it should move when the evidence moves.
That's also why I keep strategy out of the tactical meetings. I run weekly one-on-ones and a weekly leadership team meeting for the measured numbers, and a separate strategy meeting for ideas. If the theory gets argued in the weekly meeting, the plan never gets done. If it never gets argued anywhere, you can spend a year executing a theory that stopped being true in March.
What Does It Look Like in One Business?
Here's an example with made-up numbers: a Shopify brand selling dog treats, about $2 million a year. Its theory on how to win is subscriptions. Win the dog owner who reorders every month, and don't chase one-time buyers. That theory decides what goes in the plan: subscription-friendly pack sizes stay, a gift-tin line for holiday shoppers gets cut, and ad money goes to buying subscribers.
The theory rests on a few numbers. The average order is $40, the gross margin is 60%, and it costs about $50 in ads to win a new customer.
| Example customer | Orders in year one | Revenue | Gross profit at 60% | After $50 ad cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Subscriber, as planned | 10 | $400 | $240 | $190 |
| Subscriber, actual | 6 | $240 | $144 | $94 |
| Non-subscriber | 1.5 on average | $60 | $36 | -$14 |
In the strategy meeting at mid-year, the owner sees subscribers are canceling sooner than the plan assumed: six orders, not ten. The plan's subscriber number now looks too high. But the theory still holds, because a subscriber still clears $94 after the cost of the ad, and a non-subscriber still loses $14. So the strategy stays. The plan's numbers get a hard look at the next planning cycle.
If the actual row had come in below zero, the theory would be broken, and a plan built on it would be buying customers at a loss, every one of them, right on schedule.
Why Does Your Strategy Depend on Accurate Numbers?
A theory is only as good as the numbers you test it with. At Daily Grace, landed cost affected our pricing strategy and our P&L. With over 1,000 SKUs and 2,000,000 units of inventory, our spreadsheets were giving us bad or delayed data, and you can't test a theory against a number that shows up late or wrong. (An accurate, verifiable landed cost is the number one reason I built Eleven Elves, which isn't open yet.) If your margin line is a guess, start with How to Calculate Landed Cost for Shopify Products, because the 60% in the table above is only as real as the cost under it.
So write the theory down in one or two sentences. Then write the plan as a list with owners and dates. Test the first in a meeting built for ideas, and run the second in the weekly meetings built for numbers. If you want more on running the business behind the books, sign up for our strategy newsletter.
JJ
This article is general information, not tax or accounting advice. Check with your accountant about how it applies to your business.